Frame Blindess


Shoemaker and Russo (in Hoch) discuss the hazards associated with "frame blindness" and how to guard against them.  Discuss three ways you can avoid "framing traps" and provide a detailed example of each from your life experience.  Could you have framed each situation differently? What did the exercise teach you about complex decision-making? What additional tools or "frames" might have helped you through the process? How was "risk" a factor in your examples? What did you learn about yourself through this exercise?



Of the various methods that Shoemaker and Russo (Hoch, et. al., 2001) state to avoid framing traps, I have typically used surfacing a frame most often when trying to suss out an issue.  I have found this technique the most effective in capturing and accounting for as many risk elements that can be conceived.  That said, risk identification is only as effective as the knowledge, experience, and imagination of the people involved in the exercise.  Frame stretching or expansion may help identify more areas of risk, but such an attempt may border on endless “what if” scenarios.  Aside from realizing I wish the dry erase markers could smell like the old marker pens (orange, cherry, blueberry), I do find that surfacing a frame provides the most complete picture of an issue compared to other brainstorming methods. 

Aligning frames as described by Shoemaker and Russo (Hoch, et. al., 2001) can be a challenging but necessary exercise to prevent frame blindness.  More than looking to insert common elements of frames, I tend to look strands or threads of commonality that permeate between frames.  I want to know what are the attributes between these identified elements and are they visible in other frames?  A problem does arise when there just isn’t any commonality between certain frames, although this can provide an answer in and of itself and forces me onto the next element. 

Appreciating emerging frames (Hoch, et. al., 2001) is perhaps the most challenging of the three trap avoidance techniques discusses here.  Like every tech blog, odds maker, or wannabe trendsetter, correctly identifying and giving proper weight to an emerging frame can be a difficult exercise.  Cassone (2014, p. 1) offers the concept of VUCA, which stands for volatile, unknown, complex and ambiguous.  This was originally created to describe a multilateral world events model.  Developed by the United States Army War College in the 1990’s, the term has been adopted by business leaders to describe “the chaotic, turbulent, and rapidly changing internal and external conditions faced by organizations on a daily basis” (Cassone, 2014).  The risk shown here is that a frame may emerge and soon be rendered obsolete or useless.  Worse maybe the constant churn and “burned calories” in trying to constantly identify such frames. 



Cassone, M. (2014). Characteristics of transformative listening enacted by organization development practitioners

Hoch, S. J., Kunreuther, H., & Gunther, R. E. (2001). Wharton on making decisions (1st ed.). New York: Wiley

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Our assignment is to "Describe how your level of self-awareness has changed since you began your MSLD program with respect to the "Five Core Aspects of Self-Awareness"" To be perfectly honest, upon reflection of the "five core aspects of self-awareness" has made me realize how any reflections of these aspects as applied to my personal awareness was really done on a basic and simple level.  However, one item did pique my interest.   Emotional Intelligence was a term that I was exposed to from a previous class, Organizational Behavior 520.   In general terms, Goleman had built upon Mann's intelligence theory of leadership.  Mann stated that intelligence plays a key role in leadership attributes, and that Goleman's theory of emotional intelligence was a natural extension of this theory.  However, upon looking at both Mann's and Goleman's theory, little evidence was provided that first confirmed that Mann was correct, which would then ma...
Read more

Empowerment

Empowered!   Describe a time when you have been empowered to accomplish something.   Reflect on how others supported you and how the endeavor was accomplished.   How can you apply those lessons to your own followers? The best example I can provide is when I was tasked to acquire new flight planning software for our airline.   Our operation was struggling financially, but there was reason for optimism due to a new aircraft we were acquiring which stretched our operations into Europe.   This required an upgrade to a new software program that had the capability for international flight planning.   The Chief Pilot and Director of Safety had confidence in me to conduct the research and propose the most capable software for purchase.   The task itself was fairly straight forward, as the requirements were fairly obvious.   What I appreciated from both gentlemen was their counsel on presenting this information to the company owner.  ...
Read more

Decision Making

Hoch, Chapter 3 discusses the power of everyday reasoning in multistage decision-making. The text discusses the way that researchers solve multistage problems through the application of formulas (dynamic programming models) that provide the most significant chances of success. Critically think about your own decision-making process and reflect on the process you use in relation to the decision making process recommendations outlined in the article. How would you apply optimal dynamic decision analysis to predict the future impact of today's decision? Additionally, would the conclusions reached on pages 57ff. of the text improve your decision-making? How and why? Note: Hoch textbook has not arrived at this time. I tend to employ a more analytical process when it comes to purchasing a large ticket item, such as a refridgerator or car.  In looking comparing various products, I tend to look at what features and long term value is offered for a particular price point.  Th...
Read more